What's the weirdest thing someone has ever said do on a date? I'll go first. I had lit my finger on fire during that day, long story, and it smelled like burning flesh, which I had never smelled before, so I told him. And he said, hear this, he said, it's a shame that we've evolved from not liking the smell of our own burning flesh. I believe that's what's kept us from eating each other this whole time. This guy didn't want to go back out with me. This guy rejected me.