Suivre
1
13
Partager
Copier le lien sur la publication
Cookies
🍪 En cliquant "Ok", vous acceptez le stockage de cookies sur votre appareil afin d'améliorer la navigation sur le site, d'analyser l'utilisation du site et de nous aider dans nos efforts de marketing.
Audio
Texte
Ajoutez un commentaire
Hey, don't be shy, you can at me, right? Go ahead now. What I said was that it wasn't some universal rule that was practically applicable to every moral situation, which is what an objective moral truth is. The Bible is interested in making valuable people, people who have virtuous characters. So it's okay to have sometimes morally permissible and sometimes morally impermissible standards because it's moral reason.
1
6
Copier le lien sur la publication
Just to add on to the last part there, it's moral reasoning that separates the Christian from the non-Christian in terms of determining what is morally correct. So I never said the Golden Rule wasn't applicable in some circumstances and applicable in others, but it certainly isn't some universal truth, which is what I was asking you about when you said that you thought that the Golden Rule was a good place to start for all moral conversations. That's nonsense. The good place to start for all moral conversations is God's existence.
Répondre
Copier le lien sur la publication
Placing God as the summum bonum, or the greatest or highest good, is the best place to start for moral conversations because it allows you to have a variety of different perspectives in regards to how exactly we achieve Christ-likeness or God-likeness, and doesn't limit you to some kind of merely human understanding of ethics that is interested in some kind of merely representative view of some kind of golden rule.
Répondre
Copier le lien sur la publication
I didn't say that your moral view was nonsense. I said that your characterization of my view, saying that I thought the golden rule wasn't applicable in any circumstance because I critiqued your usage of it in every circumstance, is nonsense. It's not the view that I articulated to you. If I misrepresented you, you're more than welcome to call that nonsense. I never said your whole view was nonsense. Your critique doesn't apply.
1
Répondre
Copier le lien sur la publication
The golden rule may originate from Christianity, which it doesn't, by the way. The golden rule, or the sentiment of the golden rule, exists way earlier than Christianity. If that's true, right, even if it was true that it originated in Christianity, the foundation for moral truths or ethical values or to be a valuable person, the sumum bonum, would not become the rule itself. It would remain God. God would be the source and foundation and summit for these moral rules, even if the rules were universal.
Répondre
Copier le lien sur la publication
Well, the way that you frame this question is problematic. I don't think that it's a matter of my perspective versus your perspective. I don't see what is morally true as a matter of perspective. So the right answer to this question is, whoever among us has the closest articulation of what is morally right or what is morally wrong to what is true of God is the person who has the most morally upright position. It's not a matter of whose perspective is better.
Répondre
Copier le lien sur la publication
I will in the future discourage people from laughing at you while I'm doing a reductio while I'm engaging with questions I'm sorry. I didn't know that hurt your feelings. I didn't I genuinely didn't mean to do that
Répondre
Copier le lien sur la publication
I mean I don't know if you should start with the existence of God because you know not everybody has an experience with God but you have an experience with how you treat other people and how you want to be treated and for that fact I disagree that you should start with the existence of God. You just start with the moral standpoint of like how to treat people morally, what is
1
2
Copier le lien sur la publication
We can't answer the question of how to treat people morally by starting with treating people morally. It's just a circle. The reason why you start with God's existence is because God is the, if you will, the greatest good, the sumum bonum, the highest good. I'm not just starting there because I think everyone has an experience of God. I'm starting there because I believe God exists and God is true for everyone regardless of whether or not they personally believe that God exists. God does exist.
Répondre
Copier le lien sur la publication
I also never disagreed that you don't have to believe in God's existence to still hold that the Golden Rule is practically applicable in all sorts of moral situations. What God's existence is required for is the ontology of moral statements, how they exist, the stuff they're made of or the stuff that they're subsistent of, not the actual moral statements themselves that we all can believe in or not believe in.
Répondre
Copier le lien sur la publication
I don't know how to at you. I hit the add button and a bunch of people come up It's like gives me people to select from but you're not on the list, and I don't have a way to Search so I don't know I don't know how to at you, but but I would I'll figure it out
1
Copier le lien sur la publication
The beginning of my message that don't be shy, you can at me was a reference to a TikTok that I watch where it's like, don't be shy, you can at me sis, cause ain't nothing worse than a pick me bitch. That's what I was referencing, I wasn't actually saying that you should or should not at me, it was just a reference to a quote that I like to quote sometimes. But no, it's okay that you didn't at me, I saw it anyway.
1
Répondre
Copier le lien sur la publication
I think when we use terms such as hardcore Christian, we need to come to an objective definition of what hardcore, quote unquote, Christian is, you know what I'm saying? You're either a Christian or you're not. There's no Christian and hardcore and softcore Christian. But anyway, yeah, regarding the post, yeah, it is definitely a reasonable way to go about things because God has given us a conscience and given us emotions and we know what makes a Christian.
Répondre
Copier le lien sur la publication
Ajoutez un commentaire
Vivez l'expérience dans son intégralité sur l'application Stereo
Ouvrir l'appli